Carly Rosenthal working with a dog using reward-based, science-based training

What Science Really Says About Training Your Dog

If you've shopped around for a dog trainer, you've probably noticed they don't all do the same thing. Some rely heavily on corrections. Others use rewards alone. It can be confusing, and a lot of marketing language muddies the water. So I want to lay out, plainly, the approach I use and why, because you deserve to understand what's happening with your dog and to make an informed choice.

Positive reinforcement first, always

My training starts, and mostly stays, with positive reinforcement. I reinforce the behaviors we want, remove the payoff for behaviors we don't, and address the underlying emotions and environment driving a dog's choices rather than simply punishing the dog into compliance. The goal is to teach a dog what to do, not just to suppress what we don't like.

This is where the science is clearest and strongest. Reward based methods are well documented to build reliable behavior while keeping dogs confident and engaged, and research consistently shows that training rooted in reinforcement supports a strong relationship between dog and handler. For the vast majority of dogs and the vast majority of goals, this is the most effective path, and it is where we begin every single time.

A balanced, individualized approach

I describe myself as a balanced trainer, and I want to be transparent about what that means. It means positive reinforcement is my foundation and my default, but I keep a broader toolkit available for the situations that genuinely call for it. On occasion, with the right dog, the right handler, and clear guidance, that can include additional tools as part of a structured plan.

I use those tools thoughtfully, sparingly, and never as a shortcut or a substitute for teaching. When a tool is on the table, it is introduced with care, conditioned properly, paired with reinforcement for the behavior I do want, and always in service of the dog's overall welfare and long term success. If a dog is fearful, or the emotional root of a behavior has not been addressed, adding pressure is the wrong move, and I will not do it. Tools are a small, deliberate part of a much larger reward based picture, not the picture itself.

The dominance myth, retired

You've probably heard that you must be the "alpha" and dominate your dog so they don't dominate you. This idea, drawn from outdated and since discredited studies of captive wolves, has been thoroughly walked back by behavior science. Most behavior people read as a dog "being dominant," pulling, guarding, jumping, ignoring you, is far better explained by instinct, emotion, excitement, fear, or simply not having been taught yet. Treating a frightened or untrained dog as a rival to be subdued tends to make things worse, not better. Good training addresses the real cause of a behavior, not an imaginary power struggle.

What this looks like for your dog

With a reward based foundation, your dog learns because good choices pay off, which makes them eager to participate rather than braced and shut down. We build real, durable behaviors while keeping your dog confident and your relationship intact. When we hit something tougher, like reactivity, fear, or guarding, we address the feeling underneath it instead of just slapping a lid on the symptom, because that is what actually produces lasting change. And because I tailor my approach to the individual dog in front of me, no two plans look exactly alike.

Why it matters who you hire

You have every right to ask any trainer directly what methods and equipment they use, and a good one will answer you clearly and without defensiveness. My commitment is simple: I lead with reward based, science informed methods, I am honest about the full range of tools I may use, and every decision is made in the best interest of the dog in front of me. You will always know what I am doing with your dog and why.

Want a trainer who leads with positive reinforcement and tailors the plan to your dog? That is exactly what I do, and I am glad to walk you through my approach for your specific situation. Reach out for a free 30 minute consult. Your dog is treated like my own.

Sources & further reading

  • American Kennel Club, Positive Reinforcement Dog Training: The Science Behind Operant Conditioning
  • AVSAB, Position Statement on the Use of Dominance Theory in Behavior Modification of Animals
  • Ziv, G. (2017), The effects of using aversive training methods in dogs — A review, Journal of Veterinary Behavior
  • American Kennel Club, How to Curb Unwanted Dog Behaviors

Want personalised help for your dog?

Carly works with dogs and owners across Waukesha & Milwaukee County — in your home, on the trail, and wherever it helps.

Book a free 30-minute consult